The Enigmatic World of the Placebo Effect: Where Belief Becomes Medicine

Hi all,

For this newsletter, I’m writing about the intriguing, and mysterious topic of placebos. I hope you enjoy it!

Belief: The Brain's Own Elixir

I’m sure you’ve heard of placebos, probably in reference to a drug study, and how the drug did better than the placebo. Placebos tend to get pushed off to the side like this a lot, or thought of as just a control condition in many studies, but they are much much more. A placebo is a substance or procedure that on itself should have no therapeutic effect - think sugar pills, saline injections, etc. But here’s the thing, they do have an effect, and the effects can be strong!

In a meticulous double-blind experiment – where neither participant nor researcher knows the true nature of the pill; participants were divided into two groups. One received an active drug pill, while the other received a placebo. Despite the placebo being devoid of any active ingredients, when the participants were informed about the study's intent, both groups reported benefits.

The real hero behind the curtain? Our belief. That's the brain's magic potion.

The Science Behind It: Placebo Mechanisms

How does this work? Truth be told, it remains a little elusive. The strength of a placebo effect can be augmented by factors that bolster belief. A vividly coloured pill, elegant packaging, or even the mere ambience of a medical facility can set the stage. These elements, far from being superficial, amplify our expectations and, in doing so, engage our brains in a potent act of self-healing.

“The more paraphernalia you put around that belief the stronger the effect.”

Exceptions and Limitations

But let's not get carried away. Not all conditions bow to the power of placebos. Objective ailments like cancer or a broken arm, for instance, don't. It's subjective experiences like pain, mood, or sleep that are more susceptible.

Then, there's the 'nocebo' effect, the placebo's evil twin. Imagine being told a pill might bring on certain side effects, and lo and behold, your ever-dramatic brain plays it out for you.

In another study, researchers warned participants of potential side effects before administering a pill, whether it was a genuine drug or a sugar twin. Astonishingly, both groups—those on the actual substance and those on the placebo—reported experiencing the mentioned side effects. This shows that our brain's anticipatory mechanisms can manifest real physical responses, even when the cause is purely psychological.

When Brand Perception Shapes Healing

There's a tale from the annals of medicine about Nurofen (a very common brand of painkillers in Australia, similar to Advil) marketing the same pill for various pains, each with a different price point. What's remarkable is that people reported better relief from the pricier options.

Sounds wild? Consider wine. In one experiment, participants tasted wine from the same bottle but were told that one glass was from a $10 bottle and the other from a $100 bottle. Unsurprisingly, they perceived the "expensive" wine to taste better, a testament to how brand perception can shape experiences. Brain scans even revealed distinct patterns of activity based on the perceived cost of the wine.

These examples not only demonstrate the intriguing interplay between our minds and bodies but also emphasise the importance of understanding these effects in various domains, from medicine to marketing.

Homeopathy and Open-Label Placebos

Then there's homeopathy. In essence, homeopathic treatments are just water. The science community doesn't buy the 'memory of water' theory, yet some patients swear by its efficacy. It's a testament to the enduring power of belief, even in the face of limited empirical evidence.

Speaking of which, open-label placebo studies are even more interesting. Participants are told they're being given a placebo, and yet, they still report benefits.

“The mere act of doing something, like taking a pill, has power.”

Classical Conditioning: The Psychological Angle

You might be wondering: Why does this happen? Enter classical conditioning. Think about Pavlov's dogs salivating at the sound of a bell. Over time, we've associated pills with relief. Take a sugar pill, and the brain might just respond as if it were the real deal. An analogy? Trying to walk normally off a stationary escalator. Our brains are trained for motion, and even knowing it's stationary, we stumble.

So, if you are used to taking a pill to go to sleep, next time try a sugar pill and see if you fall asleep just as well.

Using Placebo to our Advantage

Here's a thought. Can we harness this for our betterment? For matters internal, those hard to control like confidence, could we use placebos? We can't just dial it up on demand, but what if dressing well, meticulous grooming, or adorning uniforms, acts as a placebo, instilling confidence and bravery?

The placebo effect, with its blend of science, psychology, and belief, is a hack unto itself. Understanding it not only gives us insights into human physiology and cognition but also potential tools to enhance our own wellbeing.

So, next time you're handed a pill or a glass of wine, or you're dressing up for a crucial event, remember, there's more at play than meets the eye.

“In the realm of placebos, belief is the key”

Have you experienced the effect of placebos or nocebos in a powerful way? How else do you think the placebo effect could be used? Leave your comments below or tweet me at @ProfJoelPearson to share your thoughts. And please share this with anyone you think could benefit from reading it!

If you have been forwarded this email and want to sign up to hear curious things about the human mind and brain, aphantasia, hyperphantasia or intuition, you can sign up here